Make Your Sandwich Pilgrimage Now

Who doesn’t love a good sandwich? Sandwiches are a great way to eat a quick lunch around the table with friends, on the go, or once you reach the trailhead. We put together a list of some of the best sandwich spots in the area, beloved by locals and visitors alike!

Bagels n Cream
2 Elm St, Delhi, NY 13753
(607) 746-8100
As the name would suggest, they have the best bagels in town. But that’s not all, this local favorite also offers a wide variety of deli sandwiches and subs, both hot and cold, along with burgers and wraps. Open for breakfast and lunch.

The Beez Kneez
21 Union Street, Sidney, NY 13838
(607) 561-9099
For cold subs, hot sandwiches, and burgers in Sidney, NY, stop by this quick server American Bistro. They also offer fresh baked goods, salads, warm beverages and other delicious fare.

Blue Bee Cafe
114 Main St, Delhi, NY 13753
(607) 746-8060
You really can’t go wrong with any of the selections on the eclectic menu at this cafe in the center of Delhi, but their old fashioned sandwiches are a standout. All are served on homemade organic bread and the portions are very generous! The homemade meatloaf sandwich is a favorite of many.

Downsville Mini-Mart
15192 NY-30, Downsville, NY 13755
(607) 363-2872
If you find yourself in Downsville, the local-lore is that the Downsville Mini-Mart makes an exceptional sandwich. Pop in to this quick-stop station to see for yourself!

84 Main Street Storefront #3, Delhi, NY 13753
(607) 746-8731
Originally a nighttime place for dinner and drinks, the folks at Hollow adjusted their business model during the pandemic by putting their evening service on hold and opening Hollow Coffee, serving incredible breakfast sandwiches and lunchtime sandwiches that are large enough for two meals. The nighttime venue has reopened, so now you can have Hollow goodness for every meal of the day.

Photo courtesy of Hollow

Hamden General Store
35796 New York 10, Hamden, NY 13782
(607) 464-4006
Tucked in the back of this modernized general store is Tiny’s Cafe. This cafe is brought to life by the Antonio Mora who uses locally sourced ingredients to create classic sandwiches with a twist. Try one Tiny’s mouthwatering sandwiches and you’ll be back to the cafe as soon as possible!

Sal’s Traditional Meat Center Inc.
51996 Main St Bloomville, NY 13739
(607) 538-1816
Sal’s is a popular local meat market and sandwich shop. Ask any local and hear them rave about their giant sandwiches and amazing subs. Open for lunch.

Townsend Street Market
87 Townsend St, Walton, NY 13856
(607) 865-4469
This small deli and convenience store located on a side street in Walton is a local favorite. Whether you order a burger, hot or cold sub or breakfast sandwich, you see why so many folks travel out of their way to visit this unassuming gem.

Russell’s General Store
2009 County Hwy 6, Bovina Center, NY 13740
(607) 832-4242
A trip to the Great Western Catskills simply is not complete without a trip to the historic Russell’s General Store for a hot breakfast sandwich, cold sub or sandwich. Made with iconic Boar’s Head brand, the sandwiches are stuffed full with generous portions and fresh toppings.

Have a favorite sandwich that should be on the list? Let us know!